THE UNTAXABLESAdvanced Strategies
Illustrative PPLI case study · New Zealand

A tale of two brothers and the tax cost of alternative investments.

On New Zealand's South Island, brothers Grant and Rhys Hollis built a thriving sheep farming business. Both put $5 million into the same US alternative investments. Grant held his inside a PPLI policy under an EWP framework, and Rhys invested directly. After 20 years, Grant's money is worth about $16.3 million more.

$29.6MGrant's $5M after 20 years, inside PPLI
$13.3MRhys's $5M after 20 years, held directly
$16.3MThe difference
Background

The Hollis brothers' investment journey

Born and raised in rural New Zealand, Grant, 52, and Rhys, 50, inherited a modest family farm and grew it into a multi-million-dollar operation through sustainable practices and global exports. Because New Zealand's economy is tied to agriculture, they diversified to reduce their exposure to commodity swings and climate risk.

$5 million each in US alternatives

By 2020, each brother had put $5 million into US-based alternative investments: private credit for steady interest, hedge funds for active trading, and real estate for depreciation benefits.

E-2 treaty investor visas

Both hold E-2 visas, which let them spend part of each year in the US managing side business interests such as agricultural tech investments.

Nonresident aliens for US tax

Spending about 120 days a year in the US, the brothers are nonresident aliens for tax purposes. They avoid US tax on their worldwide income but pay US tax on US-source investment returns.

Taxed at home too

New Zealand taxes their foreign income at rates up to 39%, with possible credits for US withholding under the US–New Zealand tax treaty: 10% on interest and 15% on dividends.

Alternative investments often produce ordinary income, such as interest from private credit or short-term gains from hedge funds. Combine US withholding, New Zealand income tax and compliance costs, and the effective rate can top 40%. Both portfolios assume a conservative 10% annual pre-tax return, diversified across asset classes. How much tax drag they carry depends on the structure.

Grant Hollis

Using PPLI and EWP for tax efficiency

Grant, the more strategic planner, consulted international specialists and placed his $5 million inside a PPLI policy under an EWP framework.

PPLI is a customized life insurance product for high-net-worth individuals. It can hold alternatives like private credit and hedge funds while providing tax-deferred growth and a death benefit free of income tax. EWP adds asset protection from creditors, privacy, succession planning that bypasses probate, and simpler compliance across jurisdictions.

A Bermuda policy

Grant's offshore PPLI policy, based in Bermuda, holds his alternatives and complies with IRS rules such as the investor control doctrine and diversification requirements.

9.3% a year, untaxed

Returns grow inside the policy with no annual tax on interest or gains. Policy fees average 0.7%, for a net 9.3% annual return.

At death

Beneficiaries receive the proceeds free of tax, which effectively eliminates estate taxes. New Zealand has no estate tax, but US estate tax could apply to US assets. For a non-US person like Grant, offshore PPLI avoids US estate tax on the policy's value, a key EWP benefit.

Fewer headaches

No Schedule K-1 delays, no phantom income, and relief from high ordinary rates on private credit, where 8% to 12% yields are usually taxed as interest.

Rhys Hollis

The cost of conventional investing

Rhys prefers simplicity, so he invests in the same alternatives directly, with no wrapper.

Taxed right away

His returns are taxed immediately: US withholding, such as 10% on interest under the treaty, plus New Zealand income tax at 39%. After credits and fees, his effective rate is around 45% to 50%.

Fees and paperwork

Management fees of 1% to 2% aren't deductible, and pass-through entities issue complex forms that add to the administrative load.

Half the yield

Private credit interest is taxed every year as ordinary income, cutting his 10% pre-tax yield to about 5% after tax.

No deferral

Short-term hedge fund gains and real estate depreciation recapture on sale add to the drag, with no way to defer. Every year, taxes shrink the capital he can reinvest, and that cost compounds.

The numbers

Twenty years, side by side

Take 20 years, from 2025 to 2045, with a steady 10% pre-tax return and no withdrawals. Grant's PPLI-EWP structure compounds at 9.3% untaxed, while Rhys's direct investments compound at 5% after tax.

The gap comes from tax inefficiency. Rhys loses half his returns to taxes every year, while Grant defers them and, through the death benefit, avoids them entirely. In private credit alone, Rhys's double-digit yields are cut in half by ordinary income tax, while Grant's grow untaxed inside the policy.

Rhys also faces liquidity issues, since illiquid alternatives make loss harvesting harder. Policy shifts are a risk too, such as US proposals to curb PPLI benefits, though offshore structures offer resilience. Grant, meanwhile, has EWP's protection across jurisdictions, a good fit for the brothers' New Zealand and US lifestyle.

Lessons learned

Tax planning as a wealth multiplier

Both brothers started with the same allocation. Grant's PPLI-EWP structure, with tax deferral, asset protection and estate planning, left him with more than $16 million extra after 20 years.

Rhys's conventional approach, weighed down by ordinary income rates, taxes similar to the US net investment income tax, and cross-border complexity, shows why global high-net-worth investors on E-2 visas need to plan ahead. For investors like the Hollis brothers, a structure like PPLI-EWP is essential for keeping the gains from alternative investments.

The story's advice is to work with tax professionals on a tailored plan, so diversification doesn't come at the cost of after-tax returns. With tax authorities watching closely, good planning can turn tax pitfalls into a chance to build generational wealth.

Walk through the PPLI guide

Or talk with your Untaxables strategist about how a structure like this could fit your own situation.